Will Republicans Get the Message?
Illinois Republican Party Chairman Bob Grogan at the Illinois State Fair in August. (Photo: Chicago Tribune)
NOTE: This story was originally posted for subscribers only. To receive subscriber-only newsletters and content, click here.
OPINION
It has been two weeks since Illinois Republican candidates were chewed down into sawdust by voters in every corner of the state.
Since then, Republican defenders, operatives, candidates, and leaders have found themselves flailing around trying to explain why their candidates took it on the chin so hard.
Yes, Donald Trump and the national environment (the dumb war in Iran that has driven gas prices through the roof and the tariff policies that have made everything you buy on Amazon more expensive) made the Republican brand so toxic to voters that they would have elected a moldy ham sandwich over most Republican options.
Republicans even took a drubbing in red states. See the Senate races in South Carolina and Mississippi or the absolute wipeout of the entire GOP statewide slate in Texas.
But it felt worse here. But was it, really?
Illinois was a +11 state for Kamala Harris in 2024. Colorado was the same.
Colorado Republicans nominated a candidate for governor who was so god-awful crazy he made Darren Bailey look like the reincarnation of Jim Edgar. Democrats won that race by one point better than Governor Pritzker won re-election. Juliana Stratton, the U.S. Senator-elect in Illinois, outperformed Colorado’s incumbent Senator, John Hickenlooper, by about a 1.5 percentage points.
It was bad for Republicans everywhere.
But you’ve seen the GOP in Illinois make that into an excuse for their poor performance on November 3. The “aw shucks, there was nothing we could do” crowd has been out in full force.
And, to a point, there were some races there was nothing they could do. Senate Republicans spent $3 million to save Sen. Seth Lewis (R-Bartlett) in his suburban district while Senate Democrats gave his DSA opponent, Ben McAdams, a frozen burrito and some bus fare and told him “good luck, kid.”
McAdams won by ten points.
The aw, shucks caucus is being drowned out, though, by the “we don’t really have a plan, but we just want to scream and shout and blame everyone but ourselves” crowd inside the Illinois GOP.
They think Illinois Republicans did a bad job motivating 2024 Trump voters to come out and vote for the GOP in 2026. But Donald Trump’s coalition has never been a Republican coalition. Donald Trump’s voters belong to that cult of personality and not to the GOP establishment. Darren Bailey could have tied his necktie to his knees and started insulting just about everyone and he wouldn’t have brought Trump’s voters out. Plus, in a lower turnout midterm in 2026, JB Pritzker got more votes than Donald Trump did in 2024. Think about that.
The handwringing inside the GOP is warranted. Losing six seats in the House (with a seventh still undecided) and five seats in the Senate, having no real challengers to make any of the 14 Democrat-held congressional seats, and not coming within a million votes in any of the statewide constitutional races should be a wake up call. This is finally rock bottom.
House Republican Leader Tony McCombie (R-Savanna) and Senate Republican Leader John Curran (R-Downers Grove) both face leadership challenges tonight. They’re likely to defeat those challengers, but having some airing of grievances inside the two caucuses is probably a good thing.
The challengers, and the unhappy voices in the caucuses, can force McCombie and Curran to lay out a plan to fix things. Maybe it will finally compel the caucuses to get serious about fundraising, which, outside of some big checks from Papa Bear Dick Uihlein in 2022, has been stagnant for five straight cycles.
The House Republican campaign operation was significantly improved in 2026, but they still didn’t have the resources to get many of their candidates up on broadcast TV where it mattered. They were catching a waterfall with a shot glass. The Senate Republican campaign message and strategy was a jumbled mess.
The Illinois Republican Party apparatus needs to reflect on itself, too. While Democrats ran a statewide coordinated campaign to contact and turn out voters, Republicans just kind of stood around with their hands in their pockets. It’s not like they’re not capable of it. The Illinois GOP had a coordinated “Victory” program in 2010 and 2012 and Bruce Rauner’s campaign had bodies on every street in the state in 2014.
Add it to the list: fundraising, messaging, ad production, candidate recruitment. All things Republicans have to do to run better campaigns.
But, more importantly, Republican primary voters need to get the message that they need to nominate candidates who can win statewide. Illinois hasn’t elected a full-on social conservative statewide since 1998. I was a freshman in high school, and let me tell you, this beard ain’t brown anymore. Social conservatives from downstate need to hold their noses come primary time and nominate candidates who have a punchers chance in November.
Any Republican who thought Darren Bailey had a chance in 2022 and, especially, in 2026, was lying to you. He fits the demographics south of I-70 wonderfully, but there’s a hell of a difference between a voter in Lake County and Lawrence County.
Republican primary voters: do you want to win or do you want to go down in a blaze of self righteous glory?
That’s not to say there isn’t some hope for the Illinois GOP somewhere down the road…way down the road.
Pete Buttigieg, the Democratic likely 2028 presidential contender and Indiana native, has often claimed there are no “permanent” red states or seats. The same can be said of blue states. Two out of the last five governors of California were Republicans. New York and Massachusetts have had Republican governors. Even Vermont, of Ben & Jerry’s and Bernie Sanders fame, just re-elected their Republican governor with 52% of the vote.
There’s a way out of the hole. But serious people need to start acting seriously and not cede control of the party to goofballs and grifters.
They can resuscitate the patient, but they have to do it fast. Or else, the Illinois GOP may be dead for good.