McCombie Survives Leadership Challenge, but Divisions Remain
House Republican Leader Tony McCombie (R-Savanna) at a news conference in 2025. (Photo: Chicago Tribune)
House Republican Leader Tony McCombie (R-Savanna) overcame a challenge from Rep. Regan Deering (R-Decatur) to win another term leading the House GOP Tuesday night.
After losing six seats in the November 3 election, McCombie has faced frustration from members of her caucus, which led Deering to jump into the race to challenge McCombie.
Sources inside the room say McCombie defeated Deering 20-13 with one “present” vote. McCombie had told members in recent days she had 21 votes, but it appears, according to multiple sources, Rep. Tom Weber (R-Lake Villa) pulled his support in recent days.
“I think you saw us come together as a caucus, air out our issues, and move forward with a plan to win races in 2028,” said one pro-McCombie member after the caucus Tuesday night. “Tony knows it was a tough election cycle and we need to sharpen our game in two years. Now we get on it.”
But McCombie, who has quarreled internally with the conservative House Freedom Caucus since taking control of the caucus in 2023, still has doubters among her members.
“When 40% of your members say you’re doing a terrible job, winning the race isn’t some kind of ringing endorsement,” another Republican member said. “We’re just going to spend the next two years doing the same thing we’ve been doing because there’s no plan to raise money or run better campaigns.”
McCombie was not made available after the caucus, did not issue a public statement, and did not respond to a message Tuesday night.
Deering didn’t comment while leaving the caucus meeting.
Senate Republican Leader John Curran (R-Downers Grove) won another term as well Tuesday night, after Republicans lost five seats November 3, dropping their already super-minority ranks to just 14 members.
Sen. Chris Balkema (R-Channahon) dropped his challenge of Curran in the hours before Tuesday night’s caucus meeting claiming Senate Republicans have agreed to a new “aggressive game plan” to win seats in 2028 and 2030.
“Since Election Day, I have talked with many of our members about how we rebuild,” Curran said in a statement. “They have brought forward constructive ideas, especially the members of my leadership team, and I am committed to putting those ideas to work. That work starts now.”
House Democrats have delayed elections for a new Speaker after Speaker Chris Welch said he wouldn’t seek another term. That battle is expected to bleed into January.